0:00
/
Generate transcript
A transcript unlocks clips, previews, and editing.

A Natural 20

The Sitting Justice Talks D&D, Oregon's Own Constitution and How to pick the right candidate for judge

Mike sits down with sitting Oregon Supreme Court Justice Bronson James — public defender and private practice lawyer turned Circuit Court, Court of Appeals, and now the state’s highest bench — for a rare, wide-ranging conversation with a sitting Justice. They start with comic-book tattoos and an actual ongoing Oregon Supreme Court Dungeons & Dragons campaign, then dig into the real stuff: what privacy even means in a world of data brokers and license plate readers, why Oregon’s 1859 constitution offers stronger protections than the federal floor, the “laboratories of democracy” under strain from federal preemption, and the perfect questions to ask judicial candidates this fall in your backyard gatherings. They close on judicial courage, Brown v. Board, and what it actually looks like when a judge is doing the job to improve the lives of the people they serve.

Topics Covered

  • Comic-book tattoos and an actual ongoing Oregon Supreme Court Dungeons & Dragons campaign

  • His path to the bench: Reed College, the dot-com boom, PhD guilt, and why he ended up in law school “not for any particular reason”

  • What surprised him at each level of the job — trial court, Court of Appeals, and now the Supreme Court

  • A plain-language tour of Oregon’s court system for non-lawyers

  • What privacy actually means today, and why the law struggles to keep pace with technology

  • Oregon’s constitution vs. the federal constitution — how Article I, Section 9 differs from the Fourth Amendment, and Hans Linde’s legacy building Oregon’s independent constitutional tradition

  • Contested judicial elections in Multnomah County this November, and the real mechanics of how judicial campaigns work

  • The information gap between lawyers (who can read a judicial candidate’s philosophy easily) and voters (who mostly can’t)

  • Why “just calling balls and strikes” is a myth, and what actually reveals a judge’s character

  • Judicial courage, Brown v. Board of Education, and MLK’s Letter from Birmingham Jail

  • Closing advice: why headlines rarely tell the full story, and how listeners can become better-informed voters on judicial races

About Our Guest

Justice Bronson James sits on the Oregon Supreme Court, appointed by Governor Kate Brown in 2022 and elected to the seat in his own right in 2024. He previously served on the Multnomah County Circuit Court and the Oregon Court of Appeals, and worked as a public defender and in private practice before that. He teaches Oregon constitutional law at Lewis & Clark Law School.

Schmidt Show PDX is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?